Solving Cross Browser Issues - Part 3 (Mootools and HTML5)



Browser Chairs

In the previous two parts, I had a look at GWT, JQuery and Dart as possible solutions for solving cross-browser issues.

In this post I am going to have a look at Mootools using the same criteria as in the previous posts and have a look at a HTML5 solution.

Mootools



Note that when I created the main snippet for this post I made use of Mootools version 1.3.2 and was forced to manually add the paste event required by my criteria (you know the event thats not supported by Opera but by everyone else).

 
// Required by older Mootools versions
 
Object.append(Element.NativeEvents, {
  'paste': 2
});
 
Element.Events.paste = {
  base : 'paste',
  condition: function(e) {
 
	// More of an afterpaste event
 
	this.fireEvent('paste', e, 1);
    return false;
  }
};
 


This all changed however with the latest version (currently 1.4.4) in which you can exclude the preceding snippet - which obviously means that the paste event is now included by default.

In the following snippet you can see the Mootools version of the criteria:

 
window.addEvent('domready', function() {
	$$('textarea').each(function(sender)
	{
		var maxlength = sender.get('maxlength');
		if (maxlength != null)
		{
			sender.addEvent('keypress', function(e){
				if ((e.code == 8) || (e.code > 36) && (e.code < 41)) return true;				
					return sender.value.length < maxlength;
			});
 
			sender.addEvent('paste', function()
			{
				setTimeout(function(){
					if(sender.value.length > maxlength)
						sender.value = sender.value.substring(0, maxlength);}, 1);
			});
		}
	});	
});
 


Looking at the snippet above you'll probably notice a few similarities to JQuery; the two technologies do infact overlap in quite a number of ways. There is nonetheless a few fundamental difference between them but I am not going to go into too much detail, read about it over here.

Like previously mentioned I initially used an older version of Mootools which gave me a different take on the technology. I felt a bit irritated about having to do something dicey in order to attach something as simple as a paste event, the exact same thing I had to do when using the GWT.

I did however start to see wisdom in an approach of excluding cross-browser unsupported functionality in a framework like Mootools (not sure if this is really one of their aims seeing that the newer version now supports the excluded event).

A framework can provide us with a way to establish boundaries, the premise being that if we play within these boundaries we'll likely be safe. We can of course still allow developers to play outside these boundaries but at their own risk of writing code thats NOT going to be cross-browser friendly (sounds like GWT/JSNI scenario).

I don't believe that the creators of Mootools & JQuery set out to create any real boundaries as such (someone correct me if I am wrong).

It would of course be very difficult to create real boundaries seeing as nothing stops the developer from accessing the raw DOM (even by accident) and using something cross-browser unfriendly.

If you were using something like GWT its a completely different matter, since you don't have real access to the raw DOM (minus using the JSNI, but thats not something you'll use by accident)

HTML5



There is currently a lot of buzz in the air about HTML5 which boasts features like:
  • Offline storage.
  • Canvas library.
  • Audio/Video support.
  • New inline elements (e.g. mark, time, meter, progress)
  • New form types (datetime, date, month, week, time, number, range, email, url)

How will this affect cross-browser issues? Well, some suggests that HTML5 will greatly improve the situation. I am personally not too conviced, especially if we look at how shady current implementations are.

Incidently the aim of the criteria used in this series of posts is to add support for something thats actually part of the HTML5 specification, but currently only implemented by 3/5 browsers - we're already busy creating workarounds.

I do nevertheless believe in HTML5 and see it as a step in the right direction.

Also in all fairness I managed to find a HTML5 solution to fully implement the criteria in 5/5 browsers, observe the following Mootools snippet.

 
window.addEvent('domready', function() {
	$$('textarea').each(function(sender)
	{
		var maxlength = sender.get('maxlength');
		if (maxlength != null)
		{
			sender.addEvent('input', function()
			{
				if(sender.value.length > maxlength)
					sender.value = sender.value.substring(0, maxlength);
			});
		}
	});	
});
 


Instead of attaching handlers to the keypress & paste event, I've only attached a handler to the input event (one of the many new events available in HTML5).

I will have a deeper look into HTML5 is future posts.

In the next part I am going to have a look at Yahoo's YUI library.







Comments



Hi Javier Thanks for the feedback, I am mainly using this script for demo purposes (most browsers support HTML5 with the maxlength attribute for textareas already - or will soon, so there is no point in using this script) But it should be fairly easy to alter this script to work more "naturally"


Good script, but it has one fail. Imagine you have a textarea with maxlength=10 and it has 10 characters; thus, you cannot write any more char. Then, select all the text inside the textarea and try to write anything. The expected behaviour is the text deleted and the new one written, but this script prevents from this.


Post comment

Name *
Email
Title
Body *
Security Code
*
* Required fields

Related Posts

Latest Posts

MS SQL: Parameter Sniffing


2012-05-21 22:38:48

Be the best stalker you can be


2011-12-13 22:33:54

Top 5 posts

Moving items between listboxes in ASP.net/PHP example


Move items between two listboxes in ASP.net(C#, VB.NET) and PHP
2008-06-12 17:07:43

Simple WYSIWYG Editor


Creating a WYSIWYG textbox for your website is actually quite simple.
2007-02-01 12:00:00

C# YouTube : Google API


Post on how to integrate with YouTube using the Google Data API
2011-03-12 08:37:51

Populate a TreeView Control C#


Populate a TreeView control in a windows application.
2009-08-27 16:01:03

Cross Browser Issues: Firefox Word Wrapping


Firefox word wrapping issues
2008-06-09 09:51:21